The protein system
Per-capita protein supply was 113.6 g per day in 2023, from 81.3 g in Slovakia to 136.9 g in Ireland.[27] In 2024 the EU produced 21.1 million tonnes of pigmeat, 14.1 million tonnes of poultry meat, 6.6 million tonnes of beef and veal and 161.8 million tonnes of raw milk.[14][16] On USDA balance data for 2025, self-sufficiency was about 115 per cent for pigmeat, 109 per cent for chicken meat and 102 per cent for beef, with cows' milk forecast at 150.0 million tonnes in 2026.[25][26] Agri-food exports reached EUR 235.4 billion against EUR 171.8 billion of imports.[28] The machinery is feed-intensive: EU farm animals eat roughly 640 million tonnes of feed a year, 395 million tonnes of it roughage, and livestock absorbs 61 per cent of internal cereal use in a sector turning over EUR 400 billion across 4 million farms.[3][6]
Two categories are in deficit. Seafood production was 3.90 million tonnes live weight in 2023 against 8.48 million tonnes of imports, a self-sufficiency rate of 38.1 per cent; for salmon, Alaska pollock, shrimp and cod, 32 per cent of consumption, self-sufficiency averaged 4 per cent.[11] Plant protein is the other: EU arable crops supplied 64 million tonnes of crude protein in 2023/24 against imports equivalent to 19 million tonnes, giving 76 per cent autonomy.[1][9][10] Within that the EU is fully self-sufficient in roughage, around 90 per cent in feed cereals, 75 per cent in rapeseed meal and about 3 per cent in soybean meal.[6][9] The Commission adopted its first Livestock Strategy and a Protein Action Plan on 7 July 2026, targeting a rise in the EU-sourced share of feed oilseeds and protein crops from around 25 to 35 per cent by 2035; that is the plan's only quantified commitment and we found no funding attached.[2][4]
Durable domestic capacity: 76
Quantitative score 79, adjusted down 3 points
On production divided by domestic supply the EU ranks among the strongest entities in the index, exporting every major meat category, dairy and cereals at a protein supply roughly double adult requirement.[14][16][27] The indicators put the pillar at 79: Europe has less land per head, a weaker fisheries position and a southern tier where water is already binding. We deduct 3 points for durability, taking the pillar to 76. Only 28 per cent of assessed EU marine stocks (76 of 270) meet both good-status criteria: 40.6 per cent in the North-East Atlantic and Baltic, but 8.6 per cent in the Mediterranean and Black Seas, where 64.8 per cent fail both.[12][32] Water scarcity affected 28 per cent of EU land area and 32 per cent of the population in 2023, and the affected area has not shrunk despite a 14 per cent fall in abstraction since 2000.[13] Cereal yield growth is projected at 0.1 per cent a year to 2035, with beef, pigmeat and sheep meat all declining, so the ratio is held up partly by falling domestic demand rather than by a growing production base.[5]
Resource headroom: 58
Quantitative score 54, adjusted up 4 points
There is almost no room to expand. Cereal area falls to 49.5 million hectares by 2035 and arable area by 0.4 per cent, while pasture declines with ruminant numbers; oilseed and pulse area grows only 2 per cent.[5] The mix is feed-intensive, pigmeat at 48 per cent of meat output and poultry 31 per cent.[14] Much of the EU's effective headroom sits abroad: 25.5 million tonnes of soy in soybean-meal equivalent was imported in 2023, several million hectares of South American cropland working on Europe's behalf.[6] Aquaculture, the usual route to cheap marine protein, is small at 1.04 million tonnes against 2.12 million tonnes of farmed imports and itself needs imported fishmeal.[6][11]
We add +4 because feed-conversion metrics understate Europe. Roughage, mostly grass, supplies 41 per cent of EU feed protein in protein-equivalent terms and the EU is fully self-sufficient in it.[6][31] A large part of the system runs on biomass humans cannot eat, on land that often cannot be cropped: standing headroom that indicators built on crop calories fed to livestock do not see.
Checked against irrigation-equipped share of arable land, agricultural credit orientation and documented cropland change, that credit does not rest on unmobilisable resource. Land equipped for irrigation covers a rising 20.2 per cent of EU arable land in 2024, up from 16.8 per cent in 2000, even as the arable base itself contracted; Eurostat's own farm-survey measure, on the larger utilised-agricultural-area denominator, puts irrigated land at 6.5 per cent and irrigable at 9.6 per cent in 2023, concentrated in Italy, Spain and France and running highest as a share of national land in Malta and Greece, the water-stressed members already flagged above.[43][45] Agricultural credit is not the constraint either. FAOSTAT's agriculture orientation index for credit, where a computable series exists for 15 of the bloc's 27 members, three-quarters of its population, comes out at a population-weighted 2.99 against a parity value of 1.00, carried by Ireland (5.54), Belgium (5.11), France (4.31) and Germany (3.77); twelve members, including Poland, the Netherlands and Romania, either report no agriculture-specific breakdown or, in the Netherlands' case, no series at all.[44] What is genuinely constrained is land: arable area fell 11.5 per cent and cropland 10.8 per cent between 2000 and 2024, 15.6 and 15.0 per cent on a per-person basis, a real and already-priced contraction rather than an unbanked resource.[43][46] The +4 stands because the constraint is exhausted land, not idle capital.
Import exposure: 74
Quantitative score 70, adjusted up 4 points
On final protein the EU imports little, and its agri-food imports are spread across the United Kingdom, Ukraine, Brazil and a long tail.[28] Poultry is the one growing meat import, 743,000 tonnes in 2025 rising to a projected 955,000 by 2035.[5][25] The exposure is concentration: of 11.4 million tonnes of soya meal imported in July to December 2025/26, Brazil supplied 52 per cent, Argentina 35 per cent and Ukraine 5 per cent, and across all oilmeals the two accounted for 80 per cent of 13.0 million tonnes.[7] On those shares the implied Herfindahl-Hirschman index for soya meal is around 0.40, among the most concentrated dependencies in this index. Soya beans are better spread: 46 per cent United States, 32 per cent Brazil, 11 per cent Canada, 10 per cent Ukraine.[7]
We add +4 for import geography, which concentration indices do not register. These flows cross the Atlantic, transit none of the world's major maritime chokepoints, and land across many deep-water gateways inside a single market that redistributes overland. When the Black Sea closed in 2022, Ukrainian maize, then 52 per cent of EU maize imports, was rerouted through solidarity lanes rather than lost.[21]
Upstream dependence: 49
Quantitative score 43, adjusted up 6 points
This is the EU's structural weakness and the reason it sits at the bottom of its band. Some 23 to 24 per cent of EU feed protein is imported, which understates the problem: 75 per cent of high-protein feed materials and about 96 per cent of soybean meal are imported, with 13.4 million tonnes of soya bean and soya meal protein brought in during 2024/25.[1][5][8] Feed is up to 50 per cent of the farm-gate value of poultry and 55 per cent for pigs, so a feed shock is a margin shock immediately.[6] As of 2021 the EU imported 85 per cent of its potash consumption, 64 per cent of those imports from Russia and Belarus, and 68 per cent of its phosphate, with Morocco at 28 per cent and Russia 23 per cent.[20] Nitrogen import dependence rose from 28 per cent in 2019 to 45 per cent in 2022, and in 2024 the bloc imported 2.0 million tonnes of ammonia and 5.9 million tonnes of urea.[22][24] Behind nitrogen sits gas: 90.0 per cent of EU natural gas was imported in 2023, and gas was up to 90 per cent of ammonia variable cost in summer 2022, when 70 per cent of capacity shut and utilisation fell to about 50 per cent.[18][20] Nitrogen consumption rebounded 5.8 per cent to 8.9 million tonnes of nutrient in 2024, still 15.8 per cent below the 2017 peak.[17]
We add +6 for the inputs Europe controls. The EU is a net exporter of breeding genetics and of veterinary and crop-protection products, hosting most of the world's poultry and pig breeding companies, and retains an ammonia and NPK industry that supplied over 90 per cent of EU nitrogen fertiliser consumption before 2022.[20] Owning the genetics and medicine layer partly substitutes for owning the feed layer, and no feed or fertiliser indicator registers it.
Access and affordability: 76
Quantitative score 80, adjusted down 4 points
This pillar is scored on the World Bank/FAO Cost and Affordability of a Healthy Diet (CoAHD) series. No official EU-27 CoAHD aggregate is published, so we computed a population-weighted bloc figure from the 27 national CoAHD readings for 2024: 8.2 per cent, against a simple unweighted average of 9.6 per cent, both inside a low unaffordability range.[40][41] The population-weighted cost of a healthy diet was Int$3.93 (PPP) per person per day.[42] Eurostat's EU-SILC measure of inability to afford a meal with meat, chicken, fish or a vegetarian equivalent every second day, retained here as a supporting indicator because it is genuinely protein-relevant, stood at 8.5 per cent for the EU-27 in 2025, unchanged from 2024 and down from 9.5 per cent in 2023, at a comparably low level.[33] Prevalence of undernourishment for Europe sits below the FAO's 2.5 per cent reporting floor and has done every year since 2000.[34] No UNICEF-WHO-World Bank Joint Malnutrition Estimate exists for the EU as a bloc or most member states;[39] the stunting component is scored on the absence of a documented burden in EU populations.
Price volatility has been material and is not fully behind the bloc. EU-27 food price inflation ran between 0.8 and 4.1 per cent across 2019 to 2021, peaked at 16.9 per cent in March 2023 as the Ukraine and gas shocks passed through to shelves, and eased to 2.9 per cent by January 2025. It then ran back up through a 2.9 to 4.0 per cent range over the rest of that year, standing at 3.1 per cent in December 2025, the latest month Eurostat publishes.[38] Physical access is generally strong on the single market's dense logistics, with the exceptions already identified elsewhere in this assessment: acute water scarcity in Cyprus and Malta, and structurally higher supply costs across the EU's island and outermost regions.[13] At 8.2 per cent, the bloc sits in the upper, worse part of that low-unaffordability range, putting the pillar at 80.
The population-weighted figure conceals a real divide. Hungary's CoAHD reading is 30.0 per cent of its population and Slovakia's 27.7 per cent, two bands below the bloc figure; Greece (23.8 per cent), Bulgaria (23.1), Romania (20.7), Latvia (17.3), Portugal (14.8), Lithuania (13.3), Croatia (12.9) and Estonia (10.2) sit one band worse than the bloc average.[40] Together these nine members hold around 15 per cent of the bloc's population. We deduct 4 points for that divergence, taking the pillar to 76. The worst-affected members are two bands down rather than three, and no single member drives the adjustment on its own.
Shock endurance: 78
Quantitative score 74, adjusted up 4 points
Because the bloc exports the protein it eats, a trade shutdown redirects supply inward rather than cutting it off, and the EUR 386.6 billion CAP for 2021 to 2027 can underwrite farm income through a price shock.[29] Twenty-seven member states provide redundancy no single country holds: compound feed output spans Spain at 27.5 million tonnes, Germany 21.5, France 19.4, Italy 14.9, the Netherlands 13.8 and Poland 11.5.[6] The European Food Security Crisis preparedness and response Mechanism has run since 9 March 2022.[21]
The weaknesses are real. There is no published bloc-level strategic protein or cereal reserve, so on reserve metrics the EU scores badly, and soya meal logistics are just-in-time. Animal disease is becoming structural: the Commission now expects highly pathogenic avian influenza to circulate year-round rather than seasonally.[5] The 2022 shock was also expensive, with urea up 200 per cent and potash 141 per cent against the 2016 to 2020 average.[20]
We add +4 for substitution slack, which stock-to-use ratios miss. With livestock absorbing 61 per cent of internal cereal use and protein supply at 113.6 g per day, a severe concentrate-feed shock is absorbable by moving cereals from feed to food and contracting monogastric herds rather than by rationing protein.[6][27] The record supports this: the EU took simultaneous gas, fertiliser and Black Sea shocks, lost most of its ammonia output and had no physical shortage, while permitting production on fallow land and mobilising EUR 500 million in farm support within weeks.[21]
Crisis purchasing power is the strongest component of this pillar's score. EU foreign-exchange reserves cover 3.35 months of imports, barely above the three-month line usually treated as adequate for an importing economy, and that ratio is flattered by intra-EU trade sitting in its denominator.[35] Reserves are the wrong lens here. The euro is a global reserve currency, so the EU buys through a disruption in a currency it issues rather than one it must stockpile, and behind it sit deep, liquid sovereign bond markets, an EU-27 government debt-to-GDP ratio of 81.7 per cent and a 2025 deficit of 3.1 per cent of GDP, both manageable by international standards, and the demonstrated ability to raise EUR 806.9 billion jointly through NextGenerationEU, of which up to EUR 637 billion is to be raised by the end of 2026 against repayment running to 2058.[36][37] That financial firepower, rather than any reserve stockpile, is what the purchasing-power component contributes to this score.
Trajectory
The Protein Action Plan will not shift this outlook much. Lifting the EU-sourced share of feed oilseeds and protein crops to 35 per cent by 2035 still leaves two-thirds of high-protein feed imported, and the Commission's own baseline has oilseed and pulse production rising 2.5 per cent over the decade with net oilseed imports falling 5.9 per cent.[1][2][5] Fertiliser policy is moving towards costly independence: duties on Russian and Belarusian nitrogen fertilisers reach roughly 100 per cent ad valorem equivalent by 2028, while the Council suspended tariffs on certain other fertilisers for a year on 22 May 2026 to hold prices down.[5][23] Reduced dependence bought with permanently higher input costs improves the upstream pillar and worsens the economics of the sector it protects.
Enlargement is the larger lever. The Commission's own scenario has Ukrainian accession lifting plant protein autonomy from 76 to 86 per cent on the strength of Ukraine's 13.5 million tonnes of annual plant protein, and Ukraine already supplies 8 per cent of EU oilmeal imports and 10 per cent of soya beans.[1][7] On a ten-year view, EU protein sovereignty is more likely to be decided in Kyiv than in CAP protein-crop payments.
The internal trend runs the other way. Beef, pigmeat and sheep meat output all fall to 2035, pigmeat by 1.54 million tonnes, under national nitrogen and greenhouse-gas rules in Ireland, the Netherlands, Belgium, Germany and Denmark.[5] Production falling alongside consumption keeps the self-sufficiency ratio intact while shrinking the absolute buffer and shifting the mix towards poultry, the most feed-intensive meat. Europe is on course to be no less self-sufficient in animal protein and no less dependent on South American soya meal to produce it.
Country notes
Unless flagged, figures are protein supply,[27] compound feed,[6] seafood consumption,[11] crop and livestock output,[14][15] oilmeal import shares,[7] water scarcity[13] and policy.[5]
Austria. 108.5 g per day, 1.73 Mt of compound feed; grassland dairy and beef leave it less soya-exposed than the pig states.
Belgium. 120.3 g per day, 6.14 Mt of compound feed, 3.02 Mt for pigs. Antwerp and Ghent are crush gateways, so it is exposed twice over; pig feed fell 7.0 per cent in 2023.
Bulgaria. 86.5 g per day, among the lowest, and 7.6 kg of seafood. Compound feed grew 7.6 per cent to 1.34 Mt in 2023, the fastest in the EU; sunflower output eases its meal dependence.
Croatia. 115.3 g per day, 23.0 kg of seafood, 0.67 Mt of static compound feed. A net meat importer whose Adriatic aquaculture runs on imported feed fish.
Cyprus. 98.7 g per day, 28.2 kg of seafood, 0.36 Mt of compound feed with effectively all concentrate imported. With Malta, the worst water scarcity of any member state in 2023.
Czechia. 96.1 g per day and the EU's lowest seafood consumption at 5.6 kg. A cereal surplus and a pigmeat deficit: it imports the animal protein its own grain could support.
Denmark. 126.3 g per day on a pigmeat sector producing 1.7 Mt. Compound feed fell 12.2 per cent in 2023, the steepest in the EU; greenhouse-gas policy will constrain herds further.
Estonia. 112.1 g per day, 17.5 kg of seafood, 0.23 Mt of compound feed. Dairy-led and tied to Baltic fisheries, the poorest-condition EU basin outside the Mediterranean.[11]
Finland. 126.1 g per day, 17.9 kg of seafood. Climate caps arable expansion, but domestic barley, oats and rapeseed cover a high share of feed protein.
France. 53.6 Mt of cereals in 2024, 20.8 per cent of the EU, and the largest beef producer at 20.0 per cent of output. It uses the most mineral nitrogen, 1.8 Mt of nutrient,[17] and takes 12 per cent of EU soya meal.
Germany. Second cereal producer at 39.1 Mt, 4.3 Mt of pigmeat, largest cheese and butter producer,[16] 21.5 Mt of compound feed. Nitrogen use fell 39.3 per cent from 2014 to 2023, the steepest cut in the EU.[17]
Greece. 112.0 g per day, 20.3 kg of seafood, compound feed estimated at 4.0 Mt. A Mediterranean aquaculture producer on imported fishmeal facing acute seasonal water scarcity: the weakest large member on headroom.
Hungary. 93.6 g per day and 5.8 kg of seafood, the second lowest. Compound feed 3.65 Mt, half poultry; maize and sunflower surpluses help, with drought the operative risk.
Ireland. The EU's highest protein supply at 136.9 g per day and the most lopsided profile anywhere: meat self-sufficiency 233 per cent in 2024, beef 701 per cent, sheep meat 385 per cent, poultry only 72 per cent.[30] The nitrates derogation governs herd size.
Italy. 116.6 g per day, 30.4 kg of seafood, 14.9 Mt of compound feed. It took about 10 per cent of EU soya bean and soya meal imports in 2025/26, and carries Po Valley irrigation exposure.
Latvia. 110.8 g per day, 21.6 kg of seafood, 0.35 Mt of compound feed. A cereal exporter that supplies feed grain while importing concentrate protein.
Lithuania. 123.8 g per day, 20.0 kg of seafood, pig feed down 24 per cent in 2023, the steepest fall of any member state. As a rapeseed exporter it feeds the one high-protein meal in which the EU is 75 per cent self-sufficient.
Luxembourg. 122.5 g per day, 29.5 kg of seafood, compound feed estimated at 90,000 t, the EU's smallest. Grassland dairy and beef with no domestic feed processing: a pure beneficiary of single-market redundancy.
Malta. 105.8 g per day, compound feed estimated at 80,000 t, and the worst seasonal water scarcity in the EU alongside Cyprus. Negligible arable land and tuna ranching on imported feed fish make it the most import-dependent member.
Netherlands. The clearest expression of the EU model: 22 per cent of EU oilseed imports and 15 per cent of soya meal through its ports in 2025/26, and 13.8 Mt of compound feed. Nitrogen policy is shrinking the herd.
Poland. Largest poultry producer at 2.9 Mt, 20.5 per cent of EU output, and third cereal producer at 34.3 Mt. It took 15 per cent of EU soya meal; milk yields rose 46 per cent from 2014 to 2024, the fastest convergence in the bloc.
Portugal. 126.4 g per day and the EU's highest seafood consumption at 53.6 kg against a deep national fish deficit. Compound feed rose 7.7 per cent to 4.44 Mt in 2023; structurally short of cereals and feed.
Romania. Fifth cereal producer at 17.9 Mt with 2.91 Mt of compound feed, mostly poultry. Maize and sunflower surpluses but thin processing: it exports raw grain and imports higher-value protein.
Slovakia. The EU's lowest protein supply at 81.3 g per day, 10.2 kg of seafood, 0.68 Mt of compound feed, poultry output cut by avian influenza in 2023. It has the least room to absorb a price shock.
Slovenia. 101.5 g per day, 11.2 kg of seafood, 0.40 Mt of compound feed, three-fifths poultry. Small, grassland-based, dependent on neighbours' supply chains.
Spain. Largest meat producer at 7.36 Mt, largest pigmeat producer at 5.0 Mt, largest compound feed producer at 27.5 Mt, largest oilmeal importer at 17 per cent of EU soya meal, and among Europe's most water-scarce large economies. Spain is where the EU's model is most exposed: output expanding, feed imported, water base contracting.
Sweden. 112.8 g per day, 1.93 Mt of compound feed, low livestock density, high grassland share. A cereal and rapeseed surplus country, among the least feed-import-exposed in relative terms.