The protein system
Two hundred and twenty-two million people[7] eat from three largely domestic systems and two imported ones. Sahelian pastoralism carries 69 million cattle, concentrated in Niger at 20.4 million head, Mali at 14.0 million and Burkina Faso at 10.3 million.[4] Rainfed cropping delivers roughly 48 million tonnes of cereals a year on the most recent GIEWS assessments, led by Mali at 10.4 million tonnes, Ghana at 6.2 million and Niger at 5.9 million,[12] supplemented by cassava, yam, cowpea and groundnut. Artisanal capture fisheries land 2.73 million tonnes, about 12.3 kilogrammes a head, with Mauritania at 640,322 tonnes, Senegal at 500,077 and Ghana at 496,159.[2]
The imported systems are rice and wheat. Senegal imports 1.66 million tonnes of milled rice against 645,000 tonnes of domestic production,[14] Côte d'Ivoire a forecast 1.7 million tonnes, Guinea 1.15 million and Ghana around 950,000.[15][16] Wheat is grown nowhere in commercial quantity: all of Ghana's 1.09 million tonnes in calendar 2025 was imported.[13]
The shape of the system is unusual. Per-capita protein supply runs from 45.0 grams a day in Liberia and 52.1 in Guinea-Bissau to 92.6 in Burkina Faso, against an African average of 65.7,[1] and undernourishment reaches 35.5 per cent in Liberia.[6] What protein there is arrives almost entirely from rangeland, rain and seawater; FAO's earlier estimates put the share of dietary protein from fish at 63 per cent in Sierra Leone and Ghana.[31] Aquaculture, the growth route taken everywhere else in the developing world, produced 159,676 tonnes in 2024, 5.5 per cent of the region's fish output, 76 per cent of it in Ghana.[3]
Durable domestic capacity: 42
Quantitative score 47, adjusted down 5 points
We score capacity at 47 before adjustment. The domestic base is real: cereal output above the five-year average in fourteen of the fifteen members, Cabo Verde's meagre maize crop being the exception,[12] with 69 million cattle[4] and 2.73 million tonnes of wild fish[2] making a protein system a trade embargo could not switch off. What fails is level and durability. Per-capita protein supply is below requirement across most of the coastal belt,[1] wheat capacity is zero[13] and rice deficits are structural.[14][15] Most seriously, the fishery carrying the animal protein is being drawn down: Ghana's small pelagic landings had fallen to under 10 per cent of their 1992 level by 2023, across 12,000 canoes supporting more than 100,000 fishers.[21]
We deduct 5 points for active conflict degrading nominal capacity, taking the pillar to 42. Mali's rice area fell 13 per cent in MY2024/25, with declines of 56 per cent in Gao and 35 per cent in Mopti, partly because insecurity kept farmers off their land.[15] Burkina Faso holds around 2.1 million displaced people, and blockaded towns have farmland their residents cannot reach.[33] The statistics report above-average harvests; the access picture does not.
Resource headroom: 47
Quantitative score 54, adjusted down 7 points
We score headroom at 54 before adjustment, the pillar most at odds with the region's poverty. The protein mix is close to feed-free: Ghana's entire feed and residual corn demand is 565,000 tonnes against 6.2 million tonnes of cereal output.[13] Fertiliser application runs at 0.77 kilogrammes per hectare in Niger, 2.7 in Sierra Leone and 8.5 in Mali, so yields of 577 kilogrammes per hectare in Niger and 1,198 in Burkina Faso sit far below the 2,688 Ghana already achieves.[7] The coastal belt is water-rich, with Liberia at 37,221 cubic metres of renewable internal freshwater per person per year and Guinea at 16,080.[7] On land and water the growth room is genuine.
Three things consume it. The Sahel is water-poor, at 82 cubic metres per person in Mauritania and 138 in Niger.[7] The marine base has passed its peak, with three of eight assessed small pelagic stocks overexploited and a roughly 60 per cent cut in fishing mortality recommended for round sardinella;[8] the EU's own Mauritanian access protocol cut the allowable small pelagic catch from 300,000 to 225,000 tonnes.[19] And demography outruns yields, with population growing 3.28 per cent a year in Niger and 2.94 in Mali;[7] FAO expects African per-capita aquatic food consumption to keep falling because supply cannot match population growth of over 25 per cent to 2032.[9][10]
We apply minus 7. The resource with immediate protein leverage is being converted from a food stock into an export feedstock, which no land or water statistic captures. Mauritanian fishmeal output peaked at 128,789 tonnes in 2020, more than half the total pelagic catch went to fishmeal plants in 2021, and it takes roughly five kilogrammes of raw fish to make one kilogramme of meal.[17][39] FAO's working group has had to recommend that Mauritania's ban on using sardinella for fishmeal be extended across the whole sub-region.[8] A second correction applies here too: a material share of the credited yield and fertiliser-gap headroom sits in Niger, Mali and Burkina Faso, roughly a third of the region's population, where active conflict already recorded under capacity is denying farmers access to their own land, and where the capital and input-distribution networks needed to close the gap to Ghana's 2,688 kilogrammes per hectare[7] do not currently reach insecure areas.
Testing the credited headroom directly against land and capital data confirms the constraint reaches beyond the conflict states. Land equipped for irrigation covers 1.75 per cent of regional cropland in 2024, barely above the 1.51 per cent of 2000 despite cropland itself growing 52 per cent over the same period; Mauritania's equipped area has not moved in a quarter-century, and only Ghana shows a large gain, from 0.56 to 3.01 per cent.[59] Agricultural credit orientation sits below parity in every one of the twelve members with a FAOSTAT series, and is falling in the largest of them: Niger's orientation index has dropped from 0.14 in 1991 to 0.035 in 2024, a three-quarters collapse, and Ghana's from 0.43 to 0.23 even as its total credit pool grew.[60] Guinea, Mauritania and Sierra Leone report no agriculture-specific credit series at all. Cropland per person fell 21 per cent regionally between 2000 and 2024 as population growth of 92 per cent outran a genuine 52 per cent expansion in cultivated area, falling in eleven of fifteen members and most sharply in Mauritania and Niger, the two states the essay already flags as fertiliser-gap-heavy.[59] The region's two clearest flagship irrigation programmes underdeliver against their own founding ambitions: Mali's Office du Niger, established in 1932 with plans for up to 1.85 million hectares, has reached roughly 100,000 after 94 years, though it still produces about 40 per cent of Mali's rice; and Ghana's USD 993 million Pwalugu dam has not broken ground on its 25,000-hectare irrigation component six years after its funded start date, its contractor having left the site.[61] Real counter-evidence survives alongside this: cropland per person rose in Cote d'Ivoire, Guinea, The Gambia and Sierra Leone, and Ghana's irrigated share nearly quintupled, so mobilisation is not zero. That potential is disclosed here rather than scored.
Import exposure: 43
Quantitative score 48, adjusted down 5 points
We score imports at 48 before adjustment. West Africa sits at the inverse of the Gulf's position. Its routes are the least chokepoint-exposed in the index: food arrives across the open Atlantic into Dakar, Nouakchott, Conakry, Abidjan, Tema, Lomé and Cotonou with no Hormuz, Suez, Bab el-Mandeb, Malacca or Panama transit, and the staple base is domestic. The exposure sits in two commodities and, in effect, one supplier. Senegal took 58 per cent of its rice from India and 17 per cent from Thailand in trade year 2024, and India's September 2022 broken-rice restrictions are the live precedent for what one supplier decision does to a 1.66 million tonne import book.[14] Wheat is imported in full, with 77 per cent of Ghana's 1.09 million tonnes from Turkey and Canada alone;[13] Russia shipped 1.7 million tonnes to the wider region in a season.[34] Food reaches 37.9 per cent of merchandise imports in Niger,[7] where GDP per capita of USD 730 leaves no capacity to outbid anyone.
We deduct 5 points, taking the pillar to 43. Within a single year the region converted three landlocked members' import corridors from an internal-market matter into a foreign-trade matter with no replacement institution. Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger formally left ECOWAS on 29 January 2025,[29][30] imposed a 0.5 per cent levy on ECOWAS-origin goods, and Niger has banned cereal exports outside the Alliance of Sahel States since October 2024,[12] while all three remain wholly dependent on coastal ports they no longer share a customs union with.
Upstream dependence: 53
Quantitative score 58, adjusted down 5 points
We score upstream at 58 before adjustment, the region's highest pillar. The incumbent system barely touches imported inputs: rangeland ruminants eat rangeland,[4] artisanal fisheries need fuel and nets rather than compound feed,[2] and pulses fix their own nitrogen. Regional fertiliser imports of roughly one million tonnes in 2022, up from 345,016 tonnes a year in the 1990s,[26] are trivial against a continent applying 18 kilogrammes per hectare against the Abuja Declaration target of 50.[27]
We deduct 5 points, taking the pillar to 53, because this independence is involuntary rather than substitutive. Every route out of 577 kilogrammes per hectare in Niger[7] or a 5.5 per cent aquaculture share[3] runs through imported urea, compound feed, fingerlings and day-old chicks, with no domestic manufacturing base beyond Senegalese phosphate rock; Nigerian urea capacity, the obvious substitute, sits inside a separately scored entity. Benin's fertiliser dependency on Russia and Ukraine combined exceeds 45 per cent, and urea prices rose about 4.5-fold after 2020.[26] Ghana pays around 30 per cent more for imported feed, faces a shortfall of some 50 million fingerlings a year and produces tilapia at USD 1.51 per kilogramme against USD 0.78 to 1.29 in the leading producers.[38]
Access and affordability: 37
Quantitative score 37, no adjustment applied
We score access at 37, positioned by the affordability indicator: a population-weighted 60.8 per cent of the fifteen states' population could not afford a healthy diet in 2024.[42] The range across members is wide. Niger is the region's worst at 86.7 per cent unaffordable, Ghana 65.8 per cent and Guinea-Bissau 65.5 per cent,[42] while The Gambia at 45.0 per cent, Senegal at 47.4 per cent and Cote d'Ivoire at 48.7 per cent are the best placed.[42]
Positioning within the band is pulled upward by the other three indicators. Weighted prevalence of undernourishment is a comparatively moderate 11.8 per cent, with Senegal at 5.1 per cent, Ghana at 6.3 per cent and Togo at 9.1 per cent offsetting Liberia at 35.5 per cent.[6] Weighted child stunting of 25.9 per cent sits below the Africa-wide average of 30.7 per cent, with Senegal, Ghana, The Gambia and Mauritania all under 18 per cent against Niger at 47.7 per cent, the region's worst.[43][44] Working the other way, domestic food price volatility is severe: Ghana's food inflation swung from 27.8 per cent in December 2024[57] to 26.5 per cent in March 2025 to 2.3 per cent in March 2026[58] and 3.3 per cent in May 2026,[45] and Niger's millet and sorghum prices moved 15 to 35 per cent within five months of 2025 alone.[12] Physical access is degraded by conflict across Mali, Burkina Faso and western Niger[33] and by landlocked dependence on coastal corridors that the AES exit from ECOWAS has complicated.[29][30] No further adjustment applies: the other indicators already point the same direction as the affordability indicator rather than against it.
Shock endurance: 43
Quantitative score 39, adjusted up 4 points
We score endurance at 39 before adjustment. This is a system where ordinary volatility already causes stress: 41.78 million people in Crisis or worse between October and December 2025, and 52.8 million projected for the June to August 2026 lean season.[11] There is no fiscal buffer, with thirteen of fifteen members below USD 2,500 GDP per capita,[7] and no meaningful reserve. After eight years the ECOWAS Regional Food Security Reserve holds 74,162 tonnes for 222 million people, roughly 0.3 kilogrammes a head, and intervenes in consignments of 500 to about 8,300 tonnes;[24] RESOGEST commits 5 per cent of national stocks across seven pilot countries.[25] The external buffer that substituted for reserves is failing: WFP suspended assistance for two million people in April 2025 and needed USD 453 million for the following six months, with 13 million children expected to be malnourished in 2026.[28] Guinea-Bissau finances its rice imports from cashews, over 90 per cent of export earnings,[36] so a commodity price move becomes a food shock with no intervening step.
Crisis purchasing power, folded in at roughly a fifth of the pillar's weight, is more mixed than the humanitarian numbers alone suggest. The eight WAEMU members pool foreign reserves at 6.1 months of import cover in 2025, a genuine buffer resting on the CFA franc's convertibility guarantee from the French Treasury,[56] but the fiscal space to draw on it is narrow: Niger's tax take is 9.1 per cent of GDP against a 20 per cent WAEMU target,[47] and Senegal is servicing a hidden-debt legacy that has pushed public debt to 118.9 per cent of GDP.[49] Mali illustrates how quickly that regional buffer can be needed close to home: a Q4 2025 terrorist blockade of the Senegal and Cote d'Ivoire transport corridors cut fuel supplies and contracted transport activity by 9.3 per cent, widening its fiscal deficit to 2.9 per cent of GDP and lowering revenue to 18.5 per cent of GDP even as debt fell to 42.3 per cent.[48] Outside the union the picture splits further, from Cabo Verde's comfortable 7.8 months of reserves[55] to Sierra Leone's 1.7 months, where debt service already exceeded 100 per cent of revenue in 2025;[52] Liberia held 1.8 months,[53] Ghana 5.7 months,[46] Mauritania 5.6 months excluding extractives,[50] The Gambia 4.5 months[51] and Guinea 3.6 months, up from 1.4 at end-2024.[54] No domestic social protection system can scale to substitute for reserves; the region has instead relied on WFP, and that substitute is now being withdrawn.[28] Purchasing power therefore adds a genuine but narrow offset rather than a second pillar of resilience.
We add 4 points for documented shock performance, taking the pillar to 43. Through the 2022 Black Sea disruption and the fertiliser price spike that followed, cereal output held at or above five-year averages in fourteen of the fifteen members with a recent assessment, by margins of 5 to 27 per cent; Cabo Verde is the exception, its 2025 maize crop coming in about 40 per cent below an already low average.[12] Substitution is observable in prices: Niger's millet and sorghum fell 15 to 35 per cent between August and December 2025 and sat below imported rice.[12] WFP's Mali data quantify the counterfactual, with crisis hunger up 64 per cent where rations were cut and down 34 per cent where they held.[28] What offsets the rest is genuine dietary breadth and rainfed domestic production that a trade shock cannot switch off.
Trajectory
Three shifts matter here, and one is already moving. Mauritania's regulatory tightening has cut fishmeal output from 128,789 tonnes in 2020 to 59,158 in 2024 and operating plants from 44 authorised in 2021 to eight by September 2025.[17] Extending that restriction to Senegal and The Gambia, as FAO's working group recommends,[8] is the highest-leverage protein intervention available and costs nothing in imports. Second, enforcement against distant-water fleets is biting from outside: the EU issued Senegal an IUU yellow card in May 2024 and let the fisheries protocol expire that November.[22][23] Third, Senegal's 2025-2034 food sovereignty strategy and Sierra Leone's Feed Salone programme[12][14] are serious input-access plans, and Ghana's free fertiliser distribution for 2026 tests whether the yield gap is a price problem.[13]
Working against this is institutional fragmentation. The AES exit removes the three most conflict-affected members from the regional reserve architecture at the moment it would matter most,[29][30] and humanitarian funding is contracting.[28] We expect the score to hold near 43 unless the fishmeal restrictions generalise; a renewed Indian rice export restriction would move imports and endurance sharply down.
Country notes
Senegal. Fisheries employ around 600,000 people, 15 per cent of the labour force, yet 322,283 tonnes were exported in 2021 out of 462,002 landed, and the EEZ is worked by a fleet flagged 32 per cent to China and 17 per cent to Spain.[20] Rice imports run to 1.66 million tonnes, 58 per cent from India.[14]
Mauritania. The largest fish producer at 640,322 tonnes[2] and the state that did most to turn food into feed, with China taking 68 per cent of 2023 fishmeal exports.[17] Also the driest, at 82 cubic metres of freshwater per person,[7] with 590,000 acutely food insecure in 2025.[12]
Mali. Largest cereal producer at 10.4 million tonnes and 14.0 million cattle,[4][12] being dismantled by conflict: 1.52 million projected into Crisis or worse for 2025, including 2,600 in Catastrophe.[12]
Niger. Diverges upwards on capacity, with 92.5 grams of protein a day,[1] 20.4 million cattle[4] and 36.2 kilogrammes of milk per person,[41] and downwards on everything else: 0.77 kilogrammes of fertiliser per hectare, yields of 577, GDP per capita of USD 730 and 3.28 per cent population growth.[7]
Burkina Faso. Recorded protein supply of 92.6 grams a day[1] and cereal output of 6.1 million tonnes, 20 per cent above average,[12] alongside 2.1 million displaced and 2.7 million acutely food insecure as of April 2026.[33] It left ECOWAS on 29 January 2025 while remaining dependent on coastal transit.[29][30]
Ghana. Aquaculture leader at 121,810 tonnes, 76 per cent of the regional total,[3] and the most advanced fishery collapse, with small pelagic landings under 10 per cent of 1992 levels.[21] Wheat is wholly imported, 77 per cent from two suppliers.[13]
Côte d'Ivoire. Best fertiliser use at 43.8 kilogrammes per hectare and second-best yields at 2,398,[7] but the largest rice importer at a forecast 1.7 million tonnes[16] with capture fisheries of only 85,494 tonnes.[2]
Guinea. The largest untapped base and weakest realisation: 16,080 cubic metres of freshwater per person against 2.9 kilogrammes of fertiliser per hectare,[7] with rice imports of 1.15 million tonnes exceeding domestic output.[15]
Benin. The lowest food-insecurity caseload at 201,000 for the 2026 lean season,[12] attached to a re-export trade: USD 109 million of poultry meat imported in 2024,[32] with fertiliser dependency on Russia and Ukraine above 45 per cent.[26]
Togo. Among the thinnest domestic bases: 477,388 cattle,[4] 20,323 tonnes of capture fisheries[2] and 5.7 kilogrammes of milk per person,[41] with 625,000 acutely food insecure, 10 per cent of the analysed population.[12]
Liberia. The weakest member: 45.0 grams of protein a day,[1] 35.5 per cent undernourishment,[6] 43,270 cattle[4] and more than 80 per cent of rice imported,[35] against the region's largest freshwater endowment at 37,221 cubic metres per person.[7]
Sierra Leone. Highest fish supply at 24.4 kilogrammes per person[5] on aquaculture of 185 tonnes,[3] with 2.7 kilogrammes of fertiliser per hectare against 19,331 cubic metres of freshwater;[7] 1.2 million acutely food insecure.[12]
The Gambia. Fish supply of 20.2 kilogrammes per person[5] on 55,075 tonnes landed,[2] with fishmeal plants associated with availability falling from 15 to 7 kilogrammes between 2017 and 2020;[18] cereal output is 135,000 tonnes for 2.8 million people.[7][12]
Guinea-Bissau. The clearest single-point failure: cashews over 90 per cent of export earnings buy the imported rice staple.[36] Fish supply of 2.35 kilogrammes per person against 54,110 tonnes landed[2][5] shows the catch leaves the country.
Cabo Verde. Diverges furthest in both directions: the highest GDP per capita at USD 5,170 and lowest population growth at 0.49 per cent,[7] with meat supply of 43.8 kilogrammes per person,[40] against maize production of 1,100 tonnes[12] and canned tuna and mackerel at 70 per cent or more of goods exports.[37]